Institutional decline: Difference between revisions
Eleutherious (talk | contribs) Second check fixes, plus material from the Circles handbook, Circle reports, LAN and Logos docs, source-checked |
Eleutherious (talk | contribs) Course no longer cited as a source: views attributed to Logos, plain facts stated plainly |
||
| (One intermediate revision by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
'''Institutional decline''' is the argument, made by the [[Logos]] movement, that centralised institutions are failing for structural reasons and that neither reform nor protest can repair them. It | '''Institutional decline''' is the argument, made by the [[Logos]] movement, that centralised institutions are failing for structural reasons and that neither reform nor protest can repair them. It is the case Logos makes for building a [[Parallel society|parallel society]]. The Logos website states that "Our institutions are failing" and that "Reform from within cannot reverse this." | ||
== The basics == | == The basics == | ||
=== Centralisation since 1648 === | === Centralisation since 1648 === | ||
The | The Logos account starts in 1648, when the Peace of Westphalia ended the Thirty Years' War. The historian Peter H. Wilson puts the war's dead at around 1.8 million soldiers and at least 3.2 million civilians. He says the losses cut the population of the Holy Roman Empire by at least a fifth. In that account, the treaties came to stand for one principle: one sovereign, one territory. | ||
Logos argues that power has moved towards the centre ever since. | Logos argues that power has moved towards the centre ever since. It lists small states absorbed into larger ones, international bodies stacked on top of them and money pulled into central banks. It marks 1971 as the year money lost its tie to gold. On 15 August that year President Nixon ordered the gold window to be closed. | ||
It also points to the growth of the state. Public spending in industrial countries averaged 8.3 percent of GDP in 1870 and 47.2 percent in 1994, according to the economists Vito Tanzi and Ludger Schuknecht. Our World in Data shows a similar rise in Europe, from around 10 percent at the end of the 19th century to close to 50 percent in many countries today. | |||
Logos argues that each step made the system more fragile and easier to corrupt. | Logos argues that each step made the system more fragile and easier to corrupt. In the Logos view, a single point that controls the money, the rules and the records is valuable enough to be captured, and in time it is. | ||
=== How failure shows up === | === How failure shows up === | ||
Logos lists patterns it says recur across countries. They include wages that buy less, corruption treated as normal, rising coercion and public services that answer to the centre. Others are a population that no longer handles things together and permits needed for simple acts. It also cites distrust of government. In the OECD's 2024 trust survey, 44 percent of respondents had low or no trust in their national government, and 39 percent had high or moderately high trust. | |||
Public debt, it adds, is climbing towards levels last seen after the Second World War. The IMF's October 2025 Fiscal Monitor projects global public debt to pass 100 percent of GDP by 2029, which would be the highest level since 1948. | |||
=== Tightening and occupation === | === Tightening and occupation === | ||
Logos argues that a failing system degrades in two directions at once. It tightens its hold through surveillance, censorship and the power to freeze assets. | Logos argues that a failing system degrades in two directions at once. It tightens its hold through surveillance, censorship and the power to freeze assets. At the same time it is occupied, as other actors take over the functions it gives up. It names cartels in Mexico, armed groups in the Sahel and corporations in Nigeria. In Michoacán, according to InSight Crime, the quotas demanded from avocado producers were fixed for everyone in the production chain. | ||
Logos uses Freedom House scores to argue that the West is not exempt. By Freedom House's measure, global freedom declined in 2025 for the 20th consecutive year. The United States fell 3 points to 81, its lowest score since the 0 to 100 scale began in 2002, adding to a 12-point erosion over two decades. Of the 88 countries rated Free, only Bulgaria matched the American drop. | |||
=== Why reform and protest fall short === | === Why reform and protest fall short === | ||
Logos argues that reform from inside fails because the system selects for people who keep it as it is, and it gives two figures. A 2019 Public Citizen study of the 115th Congress found that 26 of 44 former members working outside politics, or 59 percent, worked for lobbying firms, consulting firms, trade groups or business groups. A 1993 report by the US Merit Systems Protection Board covered its 1992 survey of federal employees. Of those who had reported illegal or wasteful activity, 37 percent said they had faced reprisal or the threat of it, up from 24 percent in the 1983 survey. The Whistleblower Protection Act was passed in 1989, between the two surveys. | |||
In its view protest also falls short, and here it draws on the political scientist Erica Chenoweth. She found that success rates for nonviolent revolutionary campaigns stayed above 40 percent from the 1960s until about 2010 and reached 65 percent in the 1990s. Since 2010, less than 34 percent have succeeded. She also found that the 2010s saw the most nonviolent resistance recorded since 1900. | |||
== How it applies to Logos == | == How it applies to Logos == | ||
Logos concludes that one option remains: building replacement institutions alongside the failing ones, so that people can rely on them when needed. It calls this a [[Parallel society|parallel society]]. Its website frames the choice as "Remain in the decline. Or exit and build the alternative." See also [[Exit]]. | |||
The Circles handbook makes the same case in its chapter [[Start a Circle/Why we need Logos Circles|Why we need Logos Circles]] | The Circles handbook makes the same case in its chapter [[Start a Circle/Why we need Logos Circles|Why we need Logos Circles]], which opens by describing a period of structural decline. It names three crises. The first is institutional collapse and a crisis of trust, the second authoritarianism and networked suppression, and the third a crisis of meaning and the collapse of community. The chapter repeats the OECD finding in its own words: "Only 4 in 10 people globally trust their national government." It also notes that the UK and Japan have appointed ministers for loneliness. | ||
The handbook's [[Start a Circle/Roadmap for Logos Circles|roadmap for Circles]] | The handbook's [[Start a Circle/Roadmap for Logos Circles|roadmap for Circles]] aims to establish Circles as trusted local institutions with real influence. It also aims to position Logos as a parallel governance system outperforming failing states. A 2026 Logos article on a Circle clean-up near Liberland describes Circles as focusing on building practical alternatives, rather than trying to reform broken or rigged institutions. | ||
=== In Circle reports === | === In Circle reports === | ||
Circle reports and handbook pages describe local problems that echo the | Circle reports and handbook pages, which are the Circles' own accounts, describe local problems that echo the Logos argument. | ||
* '''Public services that do not answer.''' The Ilorin Circle reported that | * '''Public services that do not answer.''' The Ilorin Circle reported that Nigeria's toll-free emergency line, 112, did not respond during a test of its Wahala emergency platform. A pop-up Circle near [[Circles/Liberland|Liberland]] cleared a road and riverbank in Apatin, Serbia, that the municipal rubbish collection did not serve. In Lisbon, residents of a social housing neighbourhood said they had been promised a community space for over a year. On the day of a booked meeting, the parish council office was closed. The Ruse Circle's civic reporting project starts from the view that residents' reports to the city are often filtered, delayed or communicated through one-way channels. | ||
* '''Permits for simple acts.''' The Ibadan Circle planned its first clean-up in a park | * '''Permits for simple acts.''' The Ibadan Circle planned its first clean-up in a park and sent a formal letter asking for approval. The request was declined, so the Circle cleaned a street in Bodija instead. The Abuja Circle paused a school pilot because approval was delayed, and the Kano Circle wrote that school approvals and preparation took longer than expected. The Liberland group wrote that it did not wait for permission. | ||
* '''Distrust of those in charge.''' The Kampala Circle's research on savings cooperatives found | * '''Distrust of those in charge.''' The Kampala Circle's research on savings cooperatives found trust gaps between SACCO members and leadership, along with paper records and little visibility into how member funds were used. | ||
* '''Few routes into paid work.''' The Awka Circle found that local tech talent had few clear routes into paid work, so | * '''Few routes into paid work.''' The Awka Circle found that local tech talent had few clear routes into paid work, so talent in Anambra goes unused or leaves for opportunities elsewhere. | ||
* '''Fear of reprisal.''' The Los Angeles Circle is designing a private app for whistleblowers. It argues that existing whistleblowing tools | * '''Fear of reprisal.''' The Los Angeles Circle is designing a private app for whistleblowers. It argues that existing whistleblowing tools rely on centralised hosts that can be subpoenaed or de-platformed. | ||
== Examples == | == Examples == | ||
* '''Iraq, 2003.''' On 15 February 2003 people in about 600 cities protested against the coming war. The BBC estimated that between six and ten million people took part that weekend. Guinness World Records lists the Rome rally, at about 3 million, as the largest anti-war rally | * '''Iraq, 2003.''' On 15 February 2003 people in about 600 cities protested against the coming war. The BBC estimated that between six and ten million people took part that weekend, fewer than the 15 million marchers Logos gives. Guinness World Records lists the Rome rally, at about 3 million, as the largest anti-war rally, a figure Wikipedia notes was the organisers' estimate. Police estimated 650,000 at the final rally, which most marchers did not reach. United States and allied forces attacked Iraq on 20 March 2003. | ||
* '''Egypt, 2011.''' Protests began on 25 January 2011. Hosni Mubarak resigned on 11 February and handed power to the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces. Mohamed Morsi of the Muslim Brotherhood, a movement founded in 1928, | * '''Egypt, 2011.''' Protests began on 25 January 2011. Hosni Mubarak resigned on 11 February and handed power to the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces. In 2012 the presidency went to Mohamed Morsi of the Muslim Brotherhood, a movement founded in 1928, and the military removed him on 3 July 2013. Logos uses this sequence to argue that whoever is already organised fills the space a protest opens. | ||
== See also == | == See also == | ||
| Line 58: | Line 58: | ||
== Sources == | == Sources == | ||
* | * Logos Circles training material, 2026 | ||
* [https://logos.co Logos], Logos, read 2026-11-04 | * [https://logos.co Logos], Logos, read 2026-11-04 | ||
* [https://www.rorotoko.com/micro-interviews/20100423-wilson-peter-on-europe-tragedy-history-thirty-years-war-1 Peter H. Wilson on The Thirty Years War: Europe's Tragedy, in a nutshell], Rorotoko, 23 April 2010 | * [https://www.rorotoko.com/micro-interviews/20100423-wilson-peter-on-europe-tragedy-history-thirty-years-war-1 Peter H. Wilson on The Thirty Years War: Europe's Tragedy, in a nutshell], Rorotoko, 23 April 2010 | ||
Latest revision as of 23:55, 4 November 2026
Institutional decline is the argument, made by the Logos movement, that centralised institutions are failing for structural reasons and that neither reform nor protest can repair them. It is the case Logos makes for building a parallel society. The Logos website states that "Our institutions are failing" and that "Reform from within cannot reverse this."
The basics
Centralisation since 1648
The Logos account starts in 1648, when the Peace of Westphalia ended the Thirty Years' War. The historian Peter H. Wilson puts the war's dead at around 1.8 million soldiers and at least 3.2 million civilians. He says the losses cut the population of the Holy Roman Empire by at least a fifth. In that account, the treaties came to stand for one principle: one sovereign, one territory.
Logos argues that power has moved towards the centre ever since. It lists small states absorbed into larger ones, international bodies stacked on top of them and money pulled into central banks. It marks 1971 as the year money lost its tie to gold. On 15 August that year President Nixon ordered the gold window to be closed.
It also points to the growth of the state. Public spending in industrial countries averaged 8.3 percent of GDP in 1870 and 47.2 percent in 1994, according to the economists Vito Tanzi and Ludger Schuknecht. Our World in Data shows a similar rise in Europe, from around 10 percent at the end of the 19th century to close to 50 percent in many countries today.
Logos argues that each step made the system more fragile and easier to corrupt. In the Logos view, a single point that controls the money, the rules and the records is valuable enough to be captured, and in time it is.
How failure shows up
Logos lists patterns it says recur across countries. They include wages that buy less, corruption treated as normal, rising coercion and public services that answer to the centre. Others are a population that no longer handles things together and permits needed for simple acts. It also cites distrust of government. In the OECD's 2024 trust survey, 44 percent of respondents had low or no trust in their national government, and 39 percent had high or moderately high trust.
Public debt, it adds, is climbing towards levels last seen after the Second World War. The IMF's October 2025 Fiscal Monitor projects global public debt to pass 100 percent of GDP by 2029, which would be the highest level since 1948.
Tightening and occupation
Logos argues that a failing system degrades in two directions at once. It tightens its hold through surveillance, censorship and the power to freeze assets. At the same time it is occupied, as other actors take over the functions it gives up. It names cartels in Mexico, armed groups in the Sahel and corporations in Nigeria. In Michoacán, according to InSight Crime, the quotas demanded from avocado producers were fixed for everyone in the production chain.
Logos uses Freedom House scores to argue that the West is not exempt. By Freedom House's measure, global freedom declined in 2025 for the 20th consecutive year. The United States fell 3 points to 81, its lowest score since the 0 to 100 scale began in 2002, adding to a 12-point erosion over two decades. Of the 88 countries rated Free, only Bulgaria matched the American drop.
Why reform and protest fall short
Logos argues that reform from inside fails because the system selects for people who keep it as it is, and it gives two figures. A 2019 Public Citizen study of the 115th Congress found that 26 of 44 former members working outside politics, or 59 percent, worked for lobbying firms, consulting firms, trade groups or business groups. A 1993 report by the US Merit Systems Protection Board covered its 1992 survey of federal employees. Of those who had reported illegal or wasteful activity, 37 percent said they had faced reprisal or the threat of it, up from 24 percent in the 1983 survey. The Whistleblower Protection Act was passed in 1989, between the two surveys.
In its view protest also falls short, and here it draws on the political scientist Erica Chenoweth. She found that success rates for nonviolent revolutionary campaigns stayed above 40 percent from the 1960s until about 2010 and reached 65 percent in the 1990s. Since 2010, less than 34 percent have succeeded. She also found that the 2010s saw the most nonviolent resistance recorded since 1900.
How it applies to Logos
Logos concludes that one option remains: building replacement institutions alongside the failing ones, so that people can rely on them when needed. It calls this a parallel society. Its website frames the choice as "Remain in the decline. Or exit and build the alternative." See also Exit.
The Circles handbook makes the same case in its chapter Why we need Logos Circles, which opens by describing a period of structural decline. It names three crises. The first is institutional collapse and a crisis of trust, the second authoritarianism and networked suppression, and the third a crisis of meaning and the collapse of community. The chapter repeats the OECD finding in its own words: "Only 4 in 10 people globally trust their national government." It also notes that the UK and Japan have appointed ministers for loneliness.
The handbook's roadmap for Circles aims to establish Circles as trusted local institutions with real influence. It also aims to position Logos as a parallel governance system outperforming failing states. A 2026 Logos article on a Circle clean-up near Liberland describes Circles as focusing on building practical alternatives, rather than trying to reform broken or rigged institutions.
In Circle reports
Circle reports and handbook pages, which are the Circles' own accounts, describe local problems that echo the Logos argument.
- Public services that do not answer. The Ilorin Circle reported that Nigeria's toll-free emergency line, 112, did not respond during a test of its Wahala emergency platform. A pop-up Circle near Liberland cleared a road and riverbank in Apatin, Serbia, that the municipal rubbish collection did not serve. In Lisbon, residents of a social housing neighbourhood said they had been promised a community space for over a year. On the day of a booked meeting, the parish council office was closed. The Ruse Circle's civic reporting project starts from the view that residents' reports to the city are often filtered, delayed or communicated through one-way channels.
- Permits for simple acts. The Ibadan Circle planned its first clean-up in a park and sent a formal letter asking for approval. The request was declined, so the Circle cleaned a street in Bodija instead. The Abuja Circle paused a school pilot because approval was delayed, and the Kano Circle wrote that school approvals and preparation took longer than expected. The Liberland group wrote that it did not wait for permission.
- Distrust of those in charge. The Kampala Circle's research on savings cooperatives found trust gaps between SACCO members and leadership, along with paper records and little visibility into how member funds were used.
- Few routes into paid work. The Awka Circle found that local tech talent had few clear routes into paid work, so talent in Anambra goes unused or leaves for opportunities elsewhere.
- Fear of reprisal. The Los Angeles Circle is designing a private app for whistleblowers. It argues that existing whistleblowing tools rely on centralised hosts that can be subpoenaed or de-platformed.
Examples
- Iraq, 2003. On 15 February 2003 people in about 600 cities protested against the coming war. The BBC estimated that between six and ten million people took part that weekend, fewer than the 15 million marchers Logos gives. Guinness World Records lists the Rome rally, at about 3 million, as the largest anti-war rally, a figure Wikipedia notes was the organisers' estimate. Police estimated 650,000 at the final rally, which most marchers did not reach. United States and allied forces attacked Iraq on 20 March 2003.
- Egypt, 2011. Protests began on 25 January 2011. Hosni Mubarak resigned on 11 February and handed power to the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces. In 2012 the presidency went to Mohamed Morsi of the Muslim Brotherhood, a movement founded in 1928, and the military removed him on 3 July 2013. Logos uses this sequence to argue that whoever is already organised fills the space a protest opens.
See also
- Parallel society
- Parallel polis
- Exit
- Commons governance
- Cherán
- Circles
- Start a Circle/Why we need Logos Circles
Takes on this idea
None yet. See Takes.
Sources
- Logos Circles training material, 2026
- Logos, Logos, read 2026-11-04
- Peter H. Wilson on The Thirty Years War: Europe's Tragedy, in a nutshell, Rorotoko, 23 April 2010
- Thirty Years' War, Encyclopaedia Britannica
- Nixon Ends Convertibility of US Dollars to Gold, Federal Reserve History
- Vito Tanzi and Ludger Schuknecht, Reforming Government in Industrial Countries, Finance and Development vol. 33 no. 3, IMF, September 1996
- Government Spending, Our World in Data
- Governments must better engage all citizens to tackle growing gaps in trust, OECD, 10 July 2024
- Fiscal Monitor, Foreword, IMF, October 2025
- Global public debt nearing historic high, IMF finds, MercoPress, 20 October 2025
- The Sicilianization of Mexican Drug Cartels, InSight Crime, 1 September 2020
- New Report: Global Freedom Declined for the 20th Consecutive Year in 2025, Freedom House, 2026
- US earns its lowest-ever score on freedom index, Dawn, 20 March 2026
- Revolving Congress: The Revolving Door Class of 2019 Flocks to K Street, Public Citizen, 2019
- Members of Congress never fade away, Las Vegas Sun, 17 June 2019
- Whistleblowing in the Federal Government: An Update, US Merit Systems Protection Board, October 1993
- Erica Chenoweth, The Future of Nonviolent Resistance, Journal of Democracy, July 2020
- Newsworthy, Peace Magazine, October 2020
- The Lasting Power of Nonviolent Resistance, Part 2, Harvard Weatherhead Center, 20 March 2019
- Why we need Logos Circles, Logos Circles handbook, read 2026-11-04
- Roadmap for Logos Circles, Logos Circles handbook, read 2026-11-04
- Winnable Issues from Circles, Logos Circles handbook, read 2026-11-04
- You Can Just Do Things: A Circles-Driven Liberland Cleanup, Logos, 13 May 2026
- Securing a community space for a social housing neighbourhood, Parallel Society Playbook, read 2026-11-04
- Building lasting hygiene habits in schools and orphanages, Parallel Society Playbook, read 2026-11-04
- Skills-to-employment training and internships for local tech talent, Parallel Society Playbook, read 2026-11-04
- Logos Circle Ibadan III: Our First Winnable Issue, Logos Forum, 5 September 2026
- Logos Circle Kampala Report, September 2026, Logos Forum, 28 September 2026
- 15 February 2003 Iraq War protests, Wikipedia
- Largest anti-war rally, Guinness World Records
- Iraq War, Encyclopaedia Britannica
- Egyptian revolution of 2011, Wikipedia
- Egypt Uprising of 2011, Encyclopaedia Britannica
- Muslim Brotherhood, Encyclopaedia Britannica
Page status: Outline. Stub · Outline · Usable · Guide · Star. Anyone can improve this page and change its status.